Under the BSA, what is the value of expert opinion in a trial?
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Explanation
Correct Answer:
Advisory in nature, but holds persuasive value
Explanation:
Under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), expert opinion is not treated as conclusive evidence. It is advisory in nature, meaning it is not binding on the court. However, it carries persuasive value and may assist the court in forming its judgment if it is reliable and well-supported.
Key Points:
Expert opinion is not conclusive evidence
It only assists the court in decision-making
Its value depends on its credibility and relevance
The court is free to accept or reject it
Additional Facts:
Expert opinion is covered under Section 45 (earlier Indian Evidence Act)
It is commonly used in medical, forensic, and handwriting analysis cases
Courts independently evaluate expert testimony
Important Questions:
Q1: Is expert opinion binding on the court?
Ans: No
Q2: Under which section is expert opinion covered?
Ans: Section 45
Q3: What is the value of expert opinion?
Ans: Advisory and persuasive only